Workers Compensation and Light duty
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0a04d/0a04db44ab31be69386ae658e3c62a8ca7b21ecb" alt="6475429"
I have an exempt supervisor returning from workers compensation on light duty, not his old position which required lifting and checking machinary periodically. Until he returns to his old position, should I be paying him hourly? I am unsure of how to handle this and I want to make sure we are doing this correctly.