Does the employer pay in NY?

Situation: Employee of hospital leave backpack with valuables in nurses locker room because the employee is not given a locker herself. She can't keep the backpack and belongings with her, because she works in an area that is sterile. The hospital is aware that there is a history of pilferage from the locker room; the employee (a new one) is not. The backpack is stolen when the employee is on duty. The result is that the employee has to replace the stolen items (about $700) and have the locks on her apartment in Brooklyn replaced (another $700). Is the hospital liable, since it provides lockers for all other employees, but not the group to which this employee belongs?

Comments

  • 3 Comments sorted by Votes Date Added
  • Interesting question. I'd be interested in knowing what NY's position is on this one.

    I once worked for an employer that utilized substantial numbers of temporary employees as casual labor, many of whom carried backpacks (our employees all were assigned lockers and company-owned locks). After the second backpack was stolen, we instituted a policy prohibiting casuals from bringing backpacks onto the premises and posted a notice that the company was not responsible for loss of unsecured valuables. If a casual showed up with a backpack, we told them to secure it elsewhere (e.g., in their car) or we would send them back to the temp agency.

    I think you might be setting a very dangerous (and expensive) precedent if the hospital absorbed the employee's loss and the law does not require the hospital to do so.


  • Agreed. Our company handbook makes it clear that all ees are responsible for loss/damage to any personal property they bring on company premises.
  • While it is typical that the company is not responsible.......I find it interesting that they are provided no place for their "stuff" even though the hospital was away of a history of theft from the locker room. Sound like poor management. What did she have in her bag that was worth $700.00, a laptop?!
    Sounds like the employees are in a catch - 22.
    My $0.02 worth.
    DJ The Balloonman
Sign In or Register to comment.