Performance Evaluation Schedules and Merit Increases
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0ac17/0ac17d6d0878892aa1c08740eba1d57e8ad7a893" alt="Bea Keeper"
Does anyone have a really efficient system/schedule for performance evaluations and merit increases? Our organization has a strangely convoluted schedule that is very hard to keep track of. We do not have an HRIS, unless you count ADP profile, which does not have a way to track promotions, etc. The system was created when there were only about 50 employees (before my time), and now we have grown to 126. I am open to any and every suggestion. Help!
Comments
I have looked at some HRIS systems but I do not find them user friendly. After all, we are HR people not IT experts.