arrrghggh! Rocker Dude gets voted off AI

HRinGA · May 2006

Why oh why did it have to be this way??? I can't believe he got voted off last night!! I'm so upset. I have no idea who will win now. Maybe Taylor? Someone console me, quick!

ray a · May 2006

I thought Chris was going to punch Ryan when he announced the results. I've never seen anyone look as angry as Chris did. The entire half hour Katherine seemed to be pouting thinking she was it. I liked Taylor at first, but he's starting to get on my nerves alittle. Elliot's the underdog - I'm for him.

autiger · May 2006

I too was totally in shock. I couldn't tell if Chris was stunned or angry. The way Ryan announced the result was so abrupt. Chris is from my area, so of course most fans around here were pulling for him. I too will be pullng for Elliott from now on.

dchr9203 · May 2006

[font size="1" color="#FF0000"]LAST EDITED ON 05-11-06 AT 10:08AM (CST)[/font][br][br]Poor Chris! I think he was just completely shocked, as were the rest of us who watch the show. While I think Kat is beautiful and does have talent, I think she's simply hanging on via the man-votes. And the Ace-like pouting is getting soooo irritating. At this point, I'm guessing that spasoid Taylor will make it to the end. But I gotta say, none of them impress me enough to buy a record or go see a concert.

HRinGA · May 2006

I'm not sure what to think of Taylor. He is a breath of fresh air. Any of them are compared to what's been forced down our ears lately (Spears, Simpson, etc).
But I don't know if that crosses over to record sales. Seems Idol has a hit every other year. Maybe next year will bring better results.

Irie · May 2006

I was shocked too that Chris is out. Thought for sure it would be Katherine. Anybody but Taylor please! Doesn't he remind you of Joe Cocker? (For those of you old enough to know who I'm talkin' about.)

Paul in Cannon Beach · May 2006

Is this season less talented than the others? I haven't watched a minute of the show but thats the general impression I get.

How big is looks? Ok, I did see about ten minutes of one episode and the guy singing looked like an accountant hitting the karaoke bars on Friday.

BG in AL · May 2006

Hello. I have been a member for several years, and have just realized that I have missed out on years worth of entertainment by not reading this message board! I am in Bham, AL (home of Taylor Hicks and Bo Bice) and while we are all hoping he will win, being a home-boy. I actually can't figure out how he has gotten this far to be honest, unless it is because of that "vote for the worst" thing. I'd be glad if he won though! Anyway, I love the build-a-story thing y'all have going on. -Becky

ray a · May 2006

Hey Becky, jump in and join the fun. And don't worry about Paul, he really is harmless.

dchr9203 · May 2006

We're neighbors! I'm in Huntsville, AL. At the last local chapter SHRM lunch, one of the guys at my table was childhood buddies and school mates with Taylor. He said he's been that way ("high energy") from childhood. I think he's popular because he's just plain fun to watch!

BG in AL · May 2006

Well, I take back everything I said about Taylor getting this far. He was so good last night and the night before! Elliot has a great singing voice, but not really entertaining. I can't stand Katharine - what a spoiled brat. If she wins, I'm never watching that show again.

HI dchr - I went to the Alabama State SHRM Conference yesterday. I rarely go to the local meetings (BSHRM) although I should.

LarryC · May 2006

I told my wife early on that Taylor Hicks is another Joe Cocker who, by the way, was really spastic. One of those rare ocassions where a disability becomes a strength.

HRinGA · May 2006

well, I voted for Taylor last night. My husband thinks I'm nuts. He doesn't even want to watch anymore since Daughtry was let go. However, that is probably the best thing that happened to him. Now he can choose what he wants to do instead of being forced into a contract like the winner will be. My guess is the last two will be Taylor and McFever. We'll find out tonight!!!!

Leo · May 2006

I only watch the beginning of the season with the goofballs, but people around here really take this serious. (Especially with the hometown guy.) I have seen people riding around with "Vote For Elliot" on their back windshield! I'm sure they are upset about last night.

HRinGA · May 2006

Taylor will win. There, I said it.

He may not be the best singer, but let's face it. It's not just about the vocals. You have to be an entertainer and he far outweighs McFever in that category.
Our local radio station started talking about a disclaimer that runs at the end of the show stating your votes could be thrown out at any time. I didn't catch the entire conversation. Does anybody know what that's about?

LarryC · May 2006

Yeah, I think that the votes can get thrown out when they don't line up with the best marketing scheme of the show. "Winning" the AI can add up to being a burden for the "winner" becaause of the committment that follows. I think Chris and Mandesa will be the long term winners regardless of who "wins" the marketing marathon.

BG in AL · May 2006

Mandesa was the best. Taylor should win this. If Katharine wins, then I know it is rigged! I don't buy the 33% deal either. That is just to make it seem close. I tried to vote for Taylor and never got through.

ray a · May 2006

Maybe those 33% numbers were the weighted numbers from the 3 judges and nothing to do with the callers.

I've said for a long time that Taylor is the best entertainer. And that is what counts.

HRinNH · May 2006

I actually tuned in to see the show last night. The reunions in their respective home towns was interesting to watch. But I got caught up in e-mail and the next time I looked, the two were left and the credits were rolling.

LarryC · May 2006

Cheryl, speaking of rolling, is the water still rolling through town?

HRinNH · May 2006

Yes, Larry, but flood levels have dropped enough to open roads. Schools that weren't flooded are open again. Lots of cleanup going on...

Paul in Cannon Beach · May 2006

I am so out of the loop on this American Idol thing and it bugs me.

Its all people talk about. Are Cliff notes available?

LarryC · May 2006

That's funny, Paul. Paula Abdul said the very same thing on the last show.

ray a · May 2006

What, that she's out of the loop? Or just loopy?

HRinGA · May 2006

what is up with her this year? All she can say is "I love you and your voice pierces into my soul!" Yuck!
Although my husband can't wait to see what she's wearing. =P~

BG in AL · May 2006

She's on something. I like her though! I think that seeing what Katharine is going to wear is why Katharine is still in it. We Birminghamians are proud of Taylor!

HRinGA · May 2006

SOUL PATROL!! SOUL PATROL!! SOUL PATROL!!
xB-) xB-) xB-)
:DD :DD :DD

Paul in Cannon Beach · May 2006

Wow, Fox News.com has created a special section of their news website solely for American Idol news and information. You can see it here: [url]http://www.foxnews.com/foxlife/americanidol/index.html[/url]

I'll go check my Bible but I am pretty sure that may be one of the signs of the apocalypse.

LarryC · May 2006

The seven years of tribulation start now.

ray a · May 2006

For us or for Paul?

Patty Mac · May 2006

Well - I do not know about anyone else, but I refuse to watch Idol anymore this season. Chris had talent and this voting thing cannot be based on the talent. He was great and deserved to win (and I am not saying that just because he was from NC). It is a funny thing that if he got the lowest number of votes, why could I never get through to vote for him! Makes you wonder.

arrrghggh! Rocker Dude gets voted off AI

Comments